Marie Forleo introduction


I'm Avital.

You want a present, peaceful and playful family life? I'm here to help you make that a reality.

read more

Why Not Punish?

Why don’t Peaceful Parents use “consequences” (i.e. punishments)?

The essential difference between what I refer to as “mainstream parenting” and “peaceful parenting” is this:

Mainstream parenting advocates for using punishments when children ‘misbehave’, in order to deter such behavior in the future (alongside praise and rewards to ‘reinforce’ good behavior). Peaceful parenting never does.

Punishment, as defined by google (so sue me) is “the infliction or imposition of a penalty as retribution for an offense”. In other words, the powerful person can inflict some form of pain or suffering on the weaker person, in order to force them into submission. Whenever one person is wielding their power over another, there is disconnection.

At the heart of peaceful parenting lies the belief that our connection with our children is sacred. And that it needs to be protected in order for us to have any influence on them whatsoever. Punishment is always a disconnecting agent.

Think back to a time that you were punished.

I can vividly remember being told to stand in the corner of my 1st grade classroom for talking during class. Clearly the teacher set out to ‘teach me a lesson’. I’d imagine that what she had wanted for me to learn was that talking during class disturbs others from hearing the teacher, and therefore should be avoided. Instead, tears streaming down my cheeks, some of my thoughts went along these lines:
‘This is so unfair.’

‘I am so ashamed.’

‘She is so mean.’

‘I’m so embarrassed. Everyone is looking at me.’


Not once did I think:

‘You know, she’s right, talking during class is disruptive. I shouldn’t have done that. I’ll make sure not to do it again’.


That’s because punishment has a way of creating a self-centered approach that usually falls into two camps:


  1. Externalizing the punishment
    ‘It’s not me, it’s them’. ‘I’ll show her.’ ‘Next time you won’t catch me.’ ‘She is so mean.’ ‘She doesn’t get it.’ ‘It’s not fair.’
  2. Internalizing the punishment
    ‘I’m a bad person.’  ‘I’m so ashamed.’ ‘I deserve this.’ ‘I’m unworthy.’ ‘I must be unloveable.’ ‘I got what I deserved.’


Either way, someone who is punished is never grateful. Never connected. Never thinking, ‘Hey, thanks for guiding me on ways to handle this better.; ‘Hey, thanks for understanding me.’ ‘Hey, thanks for giving me the benefit of the doubt.’ ‘Hey, thanks for being in my corner.’

Punishment has recently become an unpopular term… too blunt or harsh, perhaps, for our sensitive, millennial ears. But punishment has far from disappeared. It’s simply been reimagined as ‘consequences’. This euphemism covers all forms of punishment (with the exclusion, perhaps, of corporal)… the removal privileges, grounding, time outs and love withdrawal.

But don’t punishments work?

According to the experts, such as Dr. Laura Markham and Alfie Kohn, punishments can work at changing a behavior, but only temporarily, and for the wrong reasons. So a child who is told not to lie because they’ll be punished may stop lying for fear of punishment. They may learn that it doesn’t serve their best interest to get caught in a lie – so they had better quit it – or become a better liar.

Conversely, when a child is taught not to lie because it diminishes trust in a relationship, they’re far more likely to stop lying because they care about building trust.

What about Natural Consequences?

The only exception to this rule, that I can think of, is “natural consequences”. And, when handled with care, I think natural consequences can probably be relied upon as an important teacher for both parent and child.

Natural consequences occur when the parents do nothing, and the situation unravels naturally.

You forgot your jacket – you got cold.

You left your bike outside – it rusted.

You hit your baby brother – he cried.

You stayed up late – you were tired.

Often kids simply need to learn their own lessons –  with their parents firmly in their corner, ready to empathize and support – without stepping in to rescue.

And other times, they need rescuing. Kids brains are simply not as developed as adults and they cannot always make the action-consequence connection.

So if your 4 year old forgets his jack, rather than the “tough love” approach of – “suck it up and learn from this for next time” – you might want to step in and “save” him. Consider, if a friend of yours forgot their jack and was cold – would you share your scarf? Would you turn around and go back to get the jacket?… That’s what we do for someone we want a good relationship with, someone we care about… why not with kids?

Ultimately, whether or not you allow natural consequences to teach your kid a “lesson” will come down to intuition and temperament, what works for you and your child in the unique situation. But even when we do allow them to bear the brunt of their mistakes, we can keep the relationship in tact by being unconditionally there for them.

So what… if not punishments?

Then what?

If I can’t take away the iPad, ground them, put them in time out, how can I modify their behavior?

The answer is never a simple, clear cut tactic you can deploy. And that is the hardest part about being a peaceful parent.

Rather it’s about the relationship: compromise, negotiation, explanation, guidance. These are the tools peaceful parents have at their disposal. Alfie Kohn calls it “working with” rather than “doing to”.

We need to remind ourselves that at their core, our kids want harmony with us. If they’re ‘misbehaving’ there’s a good reason why and we (hello, sherlock) need to find it and address it.

Do you avoid punishments in your home? How about natural consequences? What do you “do” instead?

You may also like...

Create a marriage you LOVE with the partner you've got! ⁣

Parent in love to create family bliss.⁣

Are you joining us? We begin July 1st. Check out Parent In Love >> Link in bio @parentingjunkie ⁣

#parentinlove #peacefulpartnering #parentingtogether #mindfulmarriage #familybliss #loveparenting #loveparentingwithhim #loveparentingwithher

There's still time to slide right in! With just 24 hours left, all you need to do is sign up now (for $0)'ll have another 14 days to decide! #ParentInLove Link in bio @ParentingJunkie ( ...

Now look, we’re all tired of the over-inflated results that course creators are flaunting on the interwebs. We’re all suspicious of online courses actually delivering on all their bloated promises. So if you think, “Bah, just another expensive course I don’t need” - I feel you, I do. I take the same wary approach when buying new programs. ⁣

But that’s why I want to share real human beings from all walks of life who have actually been through this course and received meaningful and priceless renewals in their relationships. ⁣

Like Chelsea, who remarked: “When I joined Parent in Love, I was ready to give up on my marriage. Today, my marriage has had a complete overhaul! It's practically a different marriage altogether.”⁣

Or Tanya, who reported: "This course has ABSOLUTELY TRANSFORMED our marriage, our family life, and my own personal growth journey! We still fight, but the fights are fewer and we tend to make up quicker and in front of the kids now!"⁣

And here's what Jonna said: "I have tools that give me hope and I know how to start resolving our conflicts. I have started to notice how my own shift of thoughts changes the whole atmosphere in our home, not only between me and my hubby but with the kids also."⁣

Check out my IGTV for more amazing success stories.⁣

Parent In Love is a 6-month deep-dive online program that will transform your marriage from the inside out. ⁣

Check it out!⁣
LINK IN BIO @parentingjunkie ⁣

Ever find yourself waiting for your partner to change? Sometimes, it feels easier alone. ⁣

As much as you want and need the support - I know sometimes it can just feel easier to run your home on your own. ⁣

No one criticizing. ⁣
No one judging. ⁣
No one commenting. ⁣
No one watching. ⁣
No one adding to your to-do list with their needs.⁣
No one irritating you.⁣

Ah. Bliss. ⁣

But did you ever have these thoughts only to then think: "Yikes! That's not really what I want, is it? What's wrong with me? What's wrong with us!?"⁣

And what has waiting for your partner to change gotten you so far? ⁣

Stop waiting... ⁣

You deserve to have a happy marriage, and your kids deserve to have happy parents. ⁣

And don't wait on your partner, because the Parent In Love program is DESIGNED to be done alone - so that YOU can focus on what YOU can change: yourself.⁣

Your partner will necessarily be affected by the changes you make - because that's how relationships work, we're intertwined like that. ⁣

So TAKE A BREAK trying to change your partner right now, and finally, start to see some real transformation. ⁣

Psst... Your partner doesn't even have to KNOW you're doing the program - not that I'm suggesting you hide this from them, especially if you two are used to discussing financial investments you make - but I DO want you to know that many members have gone through Parent In Love WITHOUT letting their partners know about it. ⁣

And what happened? ⁣

Well, typically their partner would suddenly begin to NOTICE a profound (wonderful!) shift in their relationship and wonder "what's going on?!" ⁣

If you really want to take this program but you're struggling to work through their concerns, especially about the $ investment, I've provided scripts to help you have those important conversations with confidence. ⁣

Get the free Make It Happen PDF in the >>> FAQ >> (link in bio @parentingjunkie) #parentinlove

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.
Add a Comment


One Reply to “The Difference Between Punishment & Natural Consequences”

  1. I think I have a good general understanding of natural consequences versus punishment. In this occasion I am stuck though.
    My four (nearly five) year old was in the shower with me. We had a few games of nots and crosses drawing on the steamed up shower door. She’s usually very good and most of our games were a draw. But then my daughter lost twice in a row. She suddenly got very upset and took it out on the door, opening it in such a way that it came off its hinges and the roller mechanism broke. As she realised what had happened she apologised and started crying. This is not the first time that she “destroys” something out of rage and we repeatedly explain that we have to look after our environment and ask if there’s something she wants to share that’s making her angry or frustrated, etc. So connection is our response, but today I do wonder if, as part of the consequences, she needs to understand that things will need repairing and this costs money. Would saying no to an ice cream or a treat in the next few days because we need to save up to fix the door be a punishment?

Comments are closed.